Welcome
To join our community, please log in or register!
New to Avalore?
Head over to the Getting Started page to learn what you need to know!
Internet Explorer
Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to a more modern browser.

Poster A Public Proposal on Dueling
Started by MerryLights

[The following would be posted up on the noticeboard in the main square of the Spire. The handwriting is plain, but readable, and there are translations into all major languages provided.]

After multiple instances of violence and injury, I write this proposal as an amendment to the Spire's laws in an attempt to avoid further harm done. 

To begin, a few definitions: 

Sparring: A practice fight that takes place for the sake of training or entertainment. A spar takes place with non-lethal force and weapons, and no intent to truly harm the other party. When sparring, participants should not be using live weapons, instead either using various methods that cover or dull their blades and strikes, or using the training weapons provided at the sparring pit. If you are using actual weapons, or actually intend to harm someone, that is not a spar. 

Dueling: A fight that takes place either to prove strength or settle a dispute. Whether between friendly or hostile participants, a duel may use actual weapons, and there is the risk of serious injury. The terms of a duel must be decided upon beforehand by all parties involved, otherwise it is just assault. 

Death-Duel: A duel in which the end goal is the opponent's death. 

Proposal: 

To begin, I propose that we, as the residents of the Spire, adopt these definitions to avoid confusion. We all come from different cultures with different ideas and rules regarding conflict, and it is up to us to decide together which of those ideas and rules we want to have for our town.

The rules I believe we should have are as follows

  1. Spars and non-fatal duels must take place either within designated training areas, such as the sparring pit, or outside the walls of the town, such as the surrounding beaches and fields. This is to avoid clogging up the street and risking collateral damage to spectators 
  2. Duels to yield, knockout, or some other non-fatal ending must have witnesses to the agreement to duel, and a medic on hand to deal with the aftermath of the fight. The witnesses are to prevent either parties from being charged with assult if it is a true duel, and to provide testimony in case of foul play. 
  3. Death-Duels are to be banned from the Spire. I understand that in some places they are seen as a mark of honor and courage, but the fact of the matter remains that they are legally sanctioned murder. It is an abhorrent and unnecessarily violent way of trying to settle disputes, and as we saw quite recently, it often causes greater chaos and strife. 
     

I ask the people of the Spire to take my words into consideration, and I am available and open for further civil discussion on this matter.  

---

[Signature: Meridy Illuma]

  • x4
  • x4
  • x4

Somewhere below, a second slip of paper would be loosely attached...

I second this notion. Duels to the death have pointlessly, irreversibly taken the lives of far too many over what could have been settled peacefully. They have only given cause for more death to occur. Vengeance. Grief. Hatred. It festers, long after such a duel, and harms more than its participants.

The one who kills has no crime to answer for while those who grieve have no chance of seeking justice, unless they dare to act outside the law or demand a death duel of their own; which does not end well for anyone.

Consider this, from one who is left to pick up the pieces of certain acts of violence on a daily basis

Something must change, or more will be senselessly killed. Honor be damned.

- H.S

 

  • x2

A note is left upon the public proposal.

”The instinct of bystanders to intervene is valiant, but, Honor is Honor. A duel to the death is conducted by willing participants who knowingly accept the terms. To outlaw murder is just, as is the wish to outlaw the collateral cost when bystanders jump into the fray of a duel - but to outlaw the duel itself? That is not right.”

  • x4
  • x2

A chunk of bark is left near the papers, with writing in berry juice

Agreed. - Erebos

  • x1

A piece of parchment is tacked beside the proposal. The text is painted in great, splattered hews and chops.

"YOU, A COWARD WHO HAS DENIED ALL MY DUELS, AND NEVER SEEN COMBAT, SEEKS SPEAK TO THE SPIRE'S WARRIORS ON MATTERS OF HONOR AND WAR, LIKE YOU KNOW THEM?

STUPID, IDIOT. WORTHLESS, PATHETIC, FRIENDLESS WRETCH

YOU HAVE NO RIGHT. YOU HAVE NEVER DUELED. KNOWING YOUR WEAKNESS, YOU NEVER WILL."

There is no signature to the posting. 

  • x2
  • x1

[!]

 

A piece of paper has been tacked underneath, it wrote:

 

”How the fuck are loud even in writing?! Shut up!”

 

no signature has been left.

  • x3
  • x1

Another note, why not add to the parchment pile? It's almost as bad as Cadayle's writing, by almost, I mean barely better.

"A FOOLISH IDEALISM THAT SHOULD NOT BE ENTERTAINED, SPURN COMBAT AS MUCH YOU WANT, LIMITING THE SPIRE PEOPLES' ABILITY TO DEAL WITH THEIR OWN PROBLEMS WILL ONLY LEAD TO DISGRACE. WHO ELSE ARE YOU TO TRUST, IF YOU EVER FEEL WRONGED, THE GUARD? THEY ARE UNRELIABLE, JAILING A MAN FOR MERELY SPEAKING AS AN EQUAL AGAINST A COUNCILLOR, HOLDING HIM FOR LONGER THAN AN ENEMY OF PREVIOUS WAR WHO ASSAULTS US CITIZENS. THEIR GREATEST AUTHORITY IS THE MONSTER OF SHADOW THAT HOLDS TO THE GUARD CAPTAIN AS A PARASITE, STEALING ALL PERSONHOOD FROM THEM IN A SEARCH FOR FALSE JUSTICE, WHICH IS TO MEAN WHATEVER CAPRICIOUS TORMENT IT WISHES TO BRING ANY IT DEEMS FOUL.

FIND YOURSELF FAMILIAR WITH THE RITES OF WARRIORS AND THEIR PURPOSE, BEFORE YOU ATTEMPT TO CHALLENGE OUR WAYS, LEST YOU'LL LOOK AS A NAIVE CHILD ASKING A FARMER IF POTATOES SPROUT FROM TREES."

No signature.

  • x3
  • x1

🙈🙉🙊

- Signed by Moogy

A rare contribution from one who seldom voices public opinion. The ink is dark, the script flowery, elegant, and flowing. The paper is thick and cream white, torn from the binding of a journal. 

"Hospital staff. Charge for non-urgent services. Let them fight, make them pay for the damage.

Only be stupid if you can afford it.

-E.L"

 

 

  • x4
  • x1
  • x2
  • x1

[!]

*Another notice is left upon the board, adjacent to the mess of flyers. It is stamped officially.*

"While the opinions of all citizens are valued, it is important to maintain a sense of decorum
and consideration when conducting public discourse. Please remember that this board is to be used for purposes
other than argument, and that everything written on it is accessible to the public, including children.

Thank you.

- Councilor V.K."

  • x5